A contest or giveaway can lead to an influx of new followers, some of whom may disappear a few weeks later. This is a well-known phenomenon, not a sign that something is wrong. This guide focuses on one specific cause: the loss of followers following a contest. As for the many other reasons why a follower count might decrease, see Why Is My Instagram Follower Count Dropping?
Why giveaways attract people who leave
Most contests require participants to follow your account in order to enter. While some may have a genuine interest in your posts, others are only after the prize. Once a winner has been chosen, this latter group has no further reason to stay; consequently, some will unfollow you.
Other factors add to the drop:
- Giveaway-hunting accounts follow many brands, enter, and unfollow in bulk.
- Prize mismatch. If the prize has nothing to do with your niche, you attract people who have nothing to do with it either.
- Bots and spam accounts often join giveaways in large numbers.
- Cleanups by Instagram. Fake accounts may be removed over time, lowering counts.
- Natural churn. Some people would have left anyway.
Is a post-giveaway drop bad?
Not always. If the people who leave were never going to engage, your audience quality may actually improve. What matters is how many followers stay and whether they interact. A smaller, more engaged audience usually beats a larger, silent one.
The number that matters: retention
Retention tells you what share of the followers you gained during the giveaway are still following you later. You need two snapshots:
- A snapshot before the giveaway starts
- A snapshot two to four weeks after it ends
Then calculate:
- New followers during the giveaway = people in the later followers list who were not in the earlier list
- Retained = those new people who are still there at the later date
- Retention rate = retained divided by the number gained
A simple example: you had 4,000 followers before. During the giveaway you gain 1,200. Four weeks later, 700 of those 1,200 are still following you. Retention is 700 divided by 1,200, about 58 percent. That means roughly 500 people left.
There is no official benchmark, so use your own results to compare one giveaway with the next.
How to take your snapshots
Instagram does not offer a history of your followers, so you have to save your own copy.
- Before the giveaway, download your data and keep
followers_1.json. See How to Download Your Instagram Data. - After the waiting period, download your data again.
- Compare the two files. Anyone in the first file who is missing from the second has left. Anyone in the second file who was not in the first is a new follower.
- Unfollow Finder reads
followers_1.jsonandfollowing.jsonin your browser, so you can also see which of your new followers you follow, and which you do not. It does not require a login or password.
For help reading the files, see followers_1.json and following.json Explained.
What to look for in the leavers
If you can see who left, patterns often appear:
- Many accounts with no posts and no photo, which suggests bots or throwaway accounts
- Accounts that follow thousands of others, which suggests giveaway hunters
- Real accounts in your niche who left, which may mean your content did not match their expectations
This helps you decide what to change next time.
How to run giveaways that keep followers
- Make the prize relevant. Choose something your ideal follower actually wants. A gift card attracts everybody. A product from your niche attracts the right people.
- Set clear, simple entry rules. Complicated rules reduce entries but raise quality.
- Partner with accounts in your niche so the new followers come from a relevant audience.
- Follow up after the giveaway. Post content that makes the new followers glad they stayed.
- Be honest about rules and winners. Meta publishes promotion guidelines, so read them before you run one, and follow any local rules on contests.
- Do not follow back entrants automatically. See Should You Follow Everyone Back.
Clean up after the giveaway
Once your second snapshot is in hand:
- Review new followers who look like bots and remove them. Removing a follower does not block them and they are not notified.
- Decide whether you followed anyone back during the giveaway who left. Those accounts may be worth unfollowing, in small batches. See Instagram Unfollow Limit Per Day.
- Record your retention rate for next time.
Do not buy followers to fix the numbers
Paying for followers to refill a drop usually makes the problem worse. The accounts are often fake, and they can harm your engagement and your account standing. It is better to accept a smaller, real audience.
Compare your before and after export files in Unfollow Finder, in your browser, with no login and no password.